When a company has surplus cash on its balance sheet, one of the most important questions for management and boards is how best to return that capital to shareholders.
Two of the most common options are a share buyback and a tender offer. Both can be effective ways of returning capital and both can create value for shareholders. But they work in fundamentally different ways and that distinction matters.
The case for a share buyback
A conventional share buyback involves a company purchasing its own shares in the market, usually over a period of time. The attraction is clear. If management believes the company’s shares are undervalued, buying them at what it considers to be an attractive price can be a very effective use of capital.
Reducing the number of shares in issue increases EPS for continuing shareholders, assuming earnings remain constant. It can also provide support for the share price and signal management’s confidence in the company’s outlook and prospects.
Another benefit is flexibility. A company can buy shares progressively rather than committing a large amount of capital on a single day. It can also adjust the pace of the programme depending on the share price, cash generation and other capital allocation priorities.
For long-term shareholders who have no desire to sell, this can be an attractive proposition. They retain their entire investment while potentially benefiting from the increased value attributable to each remaining share.
But there is a catch. The benefit of a buyback is not necessarily felt immediately by shareholders.
The company spends cash buying shares from those shareholders who choose to sell in the market. For shareholders who continue to hold their shares, the hoped-for benefit is indirect: fewer shares in issue, potentially higher earnings per share and, ultimately, the expectation that the market will recognise the increased value of each share.
That last part is important. A buyback can improve the underlying mathematics of a business, but it doesn’t guarantee that the share price will rerate. If a company is trading on a low valuation multiple because investors have concerns about its strategy, management, sector, liquidity or growth prospects, simply buying back shares may not be enough to change that perception.
The company can therefore create theoretical value per share without necessarily seeing that value reflected in the share price.
The case for a tender offer
A tender offer takes a different approach. Rather than buying shares progressively in the market, the company offers shareholders the opportunity to sell a defined proportion of their holdings back to the company at a specified price.
This provides shareholders with something a buyback does not necessarily provide: a clear and immediate route to crystallise some of their investment.
A tender offer can also be structured so that shareholders who want to remain invested can do so, while those who want to take some money off the table have the opportunity to participate. Recent UK tender offers have explicitly highlighted this flexibility as a benefit.
For shareholders, there is also greater certainty around the price at which the transaction will take place. Depending on the terms, the tender price may represent a premium to the prevailing market price, providing shareholders with an opportunity to realise value that the market itself has not yet fully recognised.
And, importantly, the shares acquired by the company can be cancelled, reducing the number of shares in issue and potentially increasing earnings per share and other per-share metrics for continuing shareholders.
So which is better?
There isn’t a universal answer. A buyback can be the better option where a company believes its shares are materially undervalued and wants to take advantage of that over an extended period. It can be particularly attractive when management has strong conviction in the company’s future and wants to invest alongside continuing shareholders.
A tender offer can be more compelling where the board wants to return a significant amount of capital efficiently and give shareholders a defined opportunity to realise value.
There are also practical and regulatory considerations. UK Listing Rules provide for tender offers in certain circumstances, including where purchases under a general shareholder authority reach the relevant 15% threshold, while smaller market purchases can generally be made subject to specified conditions.
Ultimately, the right answer depends on the company’s circumstances, its share price, balance sheet, investment opportunities and the objectives of its shareholder base.
My view: give shareholders the choice – and the cash
Everyone has an opinion on how value is delivered to shareholders. Some investors would rather see a company buy back shares and allow the value of their remaining holding to compound over time. Others prefer to receive some of their investment back directly.
Personally, I favour the tender offer where the circumstances are right. The reason is simple: it actually puts money in shareholders’ pockets.
With a buyback, the company is effectively asking shareholders to trust that the market will eventually recognise the benefit of the transaction and rerate the company’s shares accordingly.
That may happen, but it may not.
A tender offer provides something much more tangible, shareholders who want to participate receive cash at a defined price, while those who believe in the company’s longer-term prospects can choose to remain invested.
For me, that combination is powerful. It gives shareholders value, while still allowing the company to reduce its share count and potentially enhance value per share for those who remain.
In an environment where investors are increasingly focused on disciplined capital allocation and tangible shareholder returns, sometimes the simplest measure of value creation is also the most compelling, putting money directly into shareholders’ hands.
